Masthead Image
Alice in Texas - Tea Tray in the Sky Austin Bay Blog Black Five Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler Michael Totten Grunt Doc Treacher - Blowing Smoke Cold Fury INDC Journal Drumwaster's Rants The Fat Guy Politburo Diktat Wizbang La Shawn Barber Chris Muir's Day by Day NRO Mark Steyn Protein Wisdom Truth Laid Bear Ace of Spades HQ Roger L. Simon iowahawk Patterico Vodka Pundit Powerline Blog Samizdata Lileks Tim Blair Scrappleface Little Green Footballs Michelle Malkin Instapundit
My West texas dot com
Movable Type
Quicktime Movie

Archives
Atom (XML)
RSS (XML)
RSD (XML)

Americans are Losing the Victory!


MIDLAND BLOGS


LOCAL GOVERNMENT


LOCAL MEDIA

ANDREW NAPOLITANO AND LYNNE STEWART

Here is an interesting take down of Judge (or "Judge") Andrew Napolitano, frequent commentator on Fox News and Fox Radio, by Andrew McCarthy:

Napolitano was once a midlevel state-court judge in New Jersey. Assuming for argument's sake that this experience is a sure sign of actual legal expertise, it would be an exceedingly narrow one: to wit, he might be thought an authority on the constitution and laws of the Garden State. Fox, however, has opportunistically chosen to ignore the "New Jersey" modifier in his former title and focus myopically on the "Judge" part. The network has adopted a convention whereby all Fox News correspondents refer to Napolitano on the air not by name but as "Judge." He then proceeds to expound with glib certainty on all manner of legal issues, including matters of federal law, for which he appears to have little familiarity.

McCarthy continues on why Napolitano is so wrong in his opinions on the prosecution of Lynne Stewart, lawyer of Omar Abdel Rahman, said opinions recently published in the NY Times. One might assume that an expert (or "expert") hired by a network or newspaper might confine their comments to subject matter in which they were, in fact, experts. One would apparently be wrong to make that assumption.

The Times ought to be embarrassed. Fox News ought to be more embarrassed.

Yep. Read the whole thing. It is fascinating.

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: ANDREW NAPOLITANO AND LYNNE STEWART.

TrackBack URL for this entry: